Thinning the Woodlot in Winter

Choose crop trees first, then cut what crowds them. What the Forest Service and extension sources say about release, spacing rules, basal area, oak wilt windows and leaving wildlife trees.

Pick the trees you are keeping before you pick the ones you are cutting. That is the whole method behind crop tree release, and it is the one rule that every Forest Service and extension source on woodlot thinning agrees on. Firewood is what falls out of doing it right.

The opposite habit is cutting whatever splits easily. Cornell and the New York DEC warn that taking straight trees for easy splitting lets the crooked, limby ones spread. University of New Hampshire Extension puts a price on the mistake. A 16-inch oak holds about 150 board feet, worth around $55 as sawlogs at the time of writing, against a little over $3 as about a fifth of a cord of firewood. That is more than 18 times the value, burned.

Choose crop trees first

The Forest Service’s crop tree guide, written with Tennessee and Kentucky Extension, gives the test. A crop tree is dominant or codominant, has a live crown on more than 30 percent of its height, and has no fork in the bottom 17 feet. No cankers, no dieback. Mast trees and den trees can qualify too, if wildlife is part of your goal.

Then cut the trees whose crowns touch it. UNH says to mark firewood trees whose tops touch the top of a chosen crop tree, giving it room on two to four sides. NRCS in Kentucky puts it as any crown within six feet of the upper two-thirds of the crop tree’s crown.

Release works, and the gain is measurable. In a Forest Service trial in 65-year-old cherry-maple stands, released black cherry grew about 1.0 inch in diameter over five years. Unreleased trees grew about 0.6. Trees freed on three or four sides grew 1.1 inches, against 0.6 for those with no release at all.

How many sides to open

Here the Forest Service disagrees with itself. A 1990 research paper measured growth rising with every side released. It reported that opening two sides instead of four cost roughly 0.4 to 0.8 inch of diameter growth per crop tree over five years.

The 2007 crop tree guide, from the same research group, says that for two oak species, going from two sides to four “added little benefit.” Its own advice sits in between: full release for fast growers like yellow-poplar, at least three sides for small sawtimber.

Species likely explains most of it. The 1990 paper found yellow-poplar and red oak responded better than chestnut oak. So for fast growers, open all four sides. For slower oaks, three is plenty, and two will do where a bigger opening risks wind damage.

How many crop trees per acre is less settled. Published figures run from 30 to 200. NRCS Kentucky says 30 to 50 of the best. The Forest Service’s homeowner brochure says 50 to 75 and never more than 100, and its 2007 guide caps release at 60 to 70. The higher numbers are for young stands where many stems will drop out later. For a woodlot with pole-size and larger trees, 30 to 50 is the useful range.

The spacing rules do not agree

Search for a spacing rule and you will find “the D-plus rule” as if it were one thing. It is at least three.

Texas A&M Forest Service and the Alabama Forestry Commission both publish D + 6: a 10-inch tree gets 16 feet of space. Both define D as diameter “in feet,” then add 6 to a diameter in inches. Taken as written, the rule gives under 7 feet. The near-identical wording suggests one agency copied the other, error included.

NC State Extension publishes a “D × 2 Rule” and then defines it as 1.75 times the diameter. Its worked example and every row of its table use 2. So a 12-inch tree gets 21 feet by the stated rule and 24 by the table, in the same fact sheet.

All three are written for southern pine. For a 10-inch tree they give 16, 17.5 and 20 feet. None cites a source or mentions the others. Use them as a rough check in the stand. Basal area is the better measure, because a prism can count it.

Measure basal area with a prism

NC State gives the clearest landowner method. Stand at a point with a 10-factor prism or angle gauge and turn a full circle. Each tree that counts as “in” stands for 10 square feet of basal area per acre. Nine trees in means 90 square feet. A homemade stick works too: NC State describes a 10-factor gauge as a ¾-inch target on a 25-inch stick.

For pine, the targets are published as numbers. NC State gives 60 to 110 square feet, and Alabama Extension says not below 50 because of windthrow. For upland oak-hickory, the Forest Service publishes only a stocking chart. That chart needs both basal area and trees per acre, so a prism alone will not get you there. For northern hardwoods, the 1977 Forest Service handbook gives a figure: about 70 square feet in trees 10 inches and up, and never below 50.

Whatever the target, do not take too much at once. Wisconsin’s silviculture guide says no more than 50 percent of basal area in one thinning. Missouri says no more than a third in a TSI cut. Take the third. You can always come back in a few years.

Why winter, and when not

Frozen ground is the solid reason. Minnesota Extension says most timber harvest happens on frozen soil because it limits compaction and rutting, and wet or clay soils need it. It gives no frost depth to wait for.

The common claim that winter cutting spares the bark of the trees you keep has no measurement behind it. One 1984 West Virginia study noted its logging happened in spring, while the bark was slipping, and guessed damage would be worst then. It never compared seasons.

Oak wilt is the reason that does have dates, and they vary by state. Texas says no wounding February through June. Minnesota says April through July, and Michigan April 15 through July 15. Penn State calls December through March the best time to cut oaks. Wisconsin’s news release says April through July, while its own silviculture guide closes oak stands for thinning April through October. If you have oaks, use your state’s window, and the stricter one if your state publishes two. A Texas owner on a northern rule would cut in February. That is the risk period.

Leave some of the junk

The worst trees for timber are often the best for wildlife. The University of Maryland defines a wolf tree as “a large older tree with a spreading crown and little or no timber value, but often great value for wildlife.” Penn State’s dead wood guide says thinning for firewood “often removes snags and logs” in field edges, where wildlife use is highest.

Wisconsin’s marking guide asks for at least three snags, three cavity trees and three mast trees per acre where they exist. Penn State asks for three to seven den trees in a partial cut, plus as many snags, and more near water. Purdue puts it plainly: do not remove every defective tree.

Watch the definition of high-grading too. Penn State Extension says that choosing trees “based only on size or species” counts, and that cutting just the big trees to free the small ones is a poorly designed thinning. Cut the crowders, not the giants.

Cornell puts a typical woodlot’s growth at about half a cord per acre per year. Twelve to fifteen acres, well managed, can supply the four to five cords most houses burn. Once it is cut, seasoning and stacking firewood and building a woodshed that dries wood take it from there.

Sources

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *